Monday, 9 November 2009

The struggle between Light and Dark

When making a horror game an important ingredient is the darkness. When in a dark place people tend to be more easily spooked and have a more vivid imagination, a genetic heritage passed on from our ancestors who were hunted by predators at night. Taking advantage of this is important and just changing the light level of an environment can make a huge difference in the scare factor.

Of course one cannot just turn off the lights and hope to make a scary game. The player still need to be able to see something, as watching a pitch black image is not all that exciting. The appropriate amount of light also depends on the type of environment and the type of events that will take place. If the environment is very large, then it might need to be brighter, whereas smaller rooms, where it is easier to navigate, can be darker.

Added to this the player is usually equipped with some kind of lantern or flashlight to help illuminate. In Amnesia (and the penumbra tech demo) the player has a vague light around her to help make the closest surroundings more easy to see. Penumbra Overture and Black Plague had a large blue help light when sneaking in darkness, although this had the problem of illuminating too much. Finally another trick is to add "fog" that gets blacker the longer the distance and this gives a the darkness a more thick and oppressive feel. This was used to great effect in the first Silent Hill game and gave the added visual effect of enemies emerging from the darkness a head of you.

Once starting to implement this, a huge problem appear: Darkness is Subjective! This means that a certain area willseem to have a different light level depending on who plays it and how it is played.

The first problem comes from the monitor itself and depend on:

  • Light level of the room.
  • Settings on the monitor.
This means that depending on the current setup at a player, a scene can look vastly different. The only way to get around this is by some sort of setup screen. Ever since I made Fiend I have been obsessed by this and always make sure to do preparations when playing a horror game. The problem is that most games do not provide with any such screen and when they do the setting is often far from optimum and makes game way too bright. I cannot understand how game developers can miss something as important as this and wonder if they ever did any tests in a dark room when creating the adjustment screen (or even played the game using the purposed settings). It is even worse with movies and although I can not think of anyone who has raised this problem before, it can make a huge difference when watching a horror flick.

As implied above, I think it is essential to have a good light level setup screen for a game (and would like it for movies). For Penumbra we had an in-game gamma value that could be tweaked and also a test image to calibrate against. There were however two large flaws here. First of all the judgment required ("Make this screen barely visible") is a highly subjective! Instead we should have had some simpler and more accurate test and in Amnesia we will have two squares of different light levels, where one should be visible and the other not. This is far from perfect, but avoids some of the extra subjectivity. Secondly, gamma is not all there is to it: changing the contrast makes a large difference and can make the calibration image fail. There is also the actual brightness to be change which of course also make a large difference. To make matters worse these three values (gamma, contrast and brightness) affect each other too.

The problems does not stop there though! It also turns out that the apparent light level changes depending on the light environment it is in. This illusion clearly illustrates the point:

Although it is hard to believe, the squares A and B are of exactly the same light level! A game example of this is in Silent Hill were the background light level looks much darker when the flashlight is off than when it is on. This means that when you setup your monitor to look good when flashlight is on, it looks too bright when it is turned off. The game developers should actually have decreased the ambient light when the flashlight was off in order to give the best effect. Another example is how a game can look much darker when running in windowed mode because of a brightly colored desktop image (note: windowed mode usually do make a game objectivly darker, but this problem can add to the effect).

So how to solve this struggle between light and dark? For developers it is important to always check a settings screen and adjust gamma before testing the lighting in a level. And to do this properly there must off course be good tools for doing just that. Another important thing is to always try the light level of a map in different ways. How does it look when the flashlight is on, when it's off, what happens when the fog comes rolling in, etc. Changes in the environment and gameplay can greatly affect the perceived darkness which in turn can have great effect on the game's ambiance.

It is also upon the players to make sure that they set up properly before playing. I have read several reviews where the reviewer claimed that the game was too dark and one can wonder if they really had set up properly. One can also wonder if the makers of the game gave proper direction on how a good set up would be like! There needs to measures taken on both sides to assure that a game can reach its potential to frighten.

How do you go about with setting up monitor gamma and so on? How much thought have you given this in the past?


9 comments:

  1. This is a pretty interesting point. I actually experienced some of this issue myself when showing Penumbra to a friend:

    In the first mines section of Overture, when I was playing, the area was nice and dark, you could only see a little bit in front of you, and it made things quite tense when avoiding the dog that eventually comes out.

    However, when I played on my friend's computer, his setup was completely different, and in that same section, I could see all around easily! It wasn't a big deal since I'd already finished the game by then, but I found it had nowhere near the same feeling as when I had been playing on my own computer, and didn't seem to do the level justice.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why it is not possible to somehow let the game to check how dark the user's screen is?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I assume you mean that the game could query the monitor and ask for it's current brightness and contrast? As far as I know this is not possible, but if we assume it is two major problems arise:

    1) All monitors are not the same, brightness for one will never be the same for another. Also, old CRT monitors can get darker has they got older and I guess the same is true for newer ones (using LCD, etc) so even if one somehow had values for every monitor in existence one could not be sure exactly what kind of light a specific user's monitor produced.

    2) As shown with the illusion in the post, the environment plays a large part in the perceived brightness. The cause in the illusion is that the brain will interpret brightness for different spots differently. This means that the exact same signal sent from the eye will end up being "seen" differently depending on context and colors around it. Another cause for this is that the eye adjusts depending on the ambient light where you are, by changing the size of the pupil and letting in different amounts of light. Also, if your surroundings are very bright they will overwhelm any fainter light, for example one does not see any stars at night if a bright lamp is in the field of view too.

    I covered some of this in the post, but hopefully it is more clear now!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Naturally it's a lot harder for the developer to control, but I found that one of the greatest problems I had concerning brightness in Penumbra was the fact that there was external light (from a window) shining on the monitor. Not really anything the developer can do except to put a little message in the game, but it's something to think about, right?

    ReplyDelete
  5. clean3d:
    Not sure what kinda of message you are thinking of. Please play the game in the dark? I thoink we had that though :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. To see a good use of Light and dark the best example, as always, is Thief the Dark Project from Looking Glass.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Possibly a disclaimer each time you run the game for the first time.

    "Please change your contrast/brightness so this square cannot be seen. Also, if possible, turn off your lights and turn up the volume.
    Thank you
    -Frictional Games"

    It might have been one of the older resident evils that actually suggested to play with the lights off before the game started. This might help!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I had never gave this subject much thought until penumbra. I use to always play horror games with my brightness up (I thought I was suppose to see everything) It was only until penumbra that I found getting it dark was what made it scary! So I'm glad you guys take such a strong stance on it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'll be honest, I'd hate to see fog in any form in your game. In Penumbra, and in the Thief games I liked the intense "realness" of the environment, which was really immersive, at the slightest hint of supernatural and such effects the game loses its real charm.

    As for the darkness debate, well... thick, black shadows are important, but you don't need to hide things in darkness, especially pathways, important items, enemies, that's just stupid (much more terrifying when they can be heard from the other side of a door, or something like that). So keep the path of the player visible.

    I have played with the gamma bar in the Thief games, it was really important to have hotkeys to brighten and darken the game, because darkness added immersion, but in certain dark areas I just couldn't see a damn thing (actually Thief 2 fixed this problem with portable flares). I think with Penumbra I didn't have a slightest problem.

    ReplyDelete

SiteMeter